Keyword Search Topic

 

Back to Reviews

 

 

1491: New Revelations of the Americas

Before Columbus by Charles C. Mann

 

Remember Squanto? Maybe you encountered him in a school pageant or in a children's story book: he's the "friendly Indian" who brought corn to the
Pilgrims, saving them from winter starvation and kicking off the very first
Thanksgiving feast. For all those who ever wanted to hear more about Squanto, there's a fascinating section of 1491 that tells his story. He was more than a bit-part player shuffled onto the stage, corncobs in hand, to further the Pilgrims' progress.

Squanto was an abductee, kidnapped by sailors and sold into slavery in Europe. He spoke English fluently because he'd been a living conversation piece in the parlors of London. By the time he managed to make it back to his native Massachusetts years later, his people had been nearly obliterated by European diseases. Becoming Plymouth Colony's guardian angel was his way of making a new home for himself and of gaining allies against his surviving Native enemies. His story is a lot richer and more complicated than the grade school pageants would lead us to suspect.

And that's the major theme of Charles C. Mann's 1491: the pre-contact Americas were much more than what we learned in history class. Drawing on ground-breaking research from the past two decades, Mann, an award-winning science writer and journalist, offers a series of surprising snapshots of the pre-Columbian world. He covers three main subjects, describing an America with much larger native populations than has long been thought; outlining an emerging scientific consensus that Indians came to the Americas thousands of years earlier than popularly believed; and explaining how native peoples profoundly changed the environments in which they lived by burning grasslands, building highways and cities, developing innovative farming techniques, and spreading - and in the
case of corn, even creating - useful plant species.

The picture that emerges is one that moves beyond the hoary notions of "the first immigrants" or "the environmentalist Indian." Mann instead offers a broad survey of indigenous scientific advances, fractious local politics, and the vastly diverse ways that natives structured their societies. To explain European explorers' often confusing estimates of Indian populations, Mann delves into the intriguing realm of infectious disease and explains how current theories in epidemiology account for the mass destruction of Indian communities by smallpox and other diseases. It's among the most intriguing sections of his already fascinating book.

This book will be of interest to fans of popular anthropology in works like
Michael Pollan's The Botany of Desire or Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel, and it's simply a must-read for those interested in Native America or in environmental histories by the likes of Donald Worster or William Cronin. More than a collection of surprising facts, theories, and discoveries, 1491 explodes the idea that Native Americans had no history before the arrival of Europeans, and it is an excellent introduction to the many American societies that gave the world not only corn and cranberries but also, to paraphrase Mann, more than a thousand different ways of being human.

Review by Mark Bradshaw, November 24, 2005


 


Back to Reviews